Key takeaways
- Manual vs cordless rivet guns compared: Marson, Astro and Arrow hand riveters against Milwaukee and DEWALT cordless tools, with sizes and battery notes.
- Top Pick: Arconic Marson 39000 HP-2 Hand Rivet Tool
- Runner-up: Arconic Marson 39000 HP-2 Hand Rivet Tool
- Also consider: Arconic Marson 39000 HP-2 Hand Rivet Tool
Blind rivets, often called pop rivets, join sheet metal, brackets, duct sections and trim without access to the back of the work. Every rivet gun does the same job: it pulls the rivet’s mandrel until the body swells, clamps the parts, and snaps the mandrel off. The real choice is how that pulling force is produced. A manual rivet gun turns your hand squeeze into pulling force through leverage, while a cordless rivet gun uses a motor and battery pack to do the pulling for you.
This comparison looks at three manual tools, the Marson HP-2, the Astro 1423 and the Arrow RT188M, against two cordless tools, the Milwaukee M12 2550-20 and the DEWALT DCF403B. The manual side asks nothing but effort and suits occasional repair work. The cordless side trades a battery platform commitment for speed and consistency across long runs of rivets. Which side wins depends on how many rivets you set, their sizes and materials, and which batteries already sit on your shelf.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases.
Quick answer
Choose a manual rivet gun if you set rivets occasionally: the Marson, Astro and Arrow hand tools need no battery and handle small repair jobs well. Choose cordless for long runs: the Milwaukee M12 and DEWALT 20V MAX XR tools set each rivet with one trigger pull and stay consistent across hundreds of fasteners.
Arconic Marson 39000 HP-2 Hand Rivet Tool
The Marson HP-2 is the classic two-handle manual riveter and the benchmark for the hand-tool side of this comparison. Its long handles multiply your squeeze force, which matters most with larger rivets and harder materials. Per the maker’s manual, it is rated for steel and aluminum rivets from 3/32 to 3/16 inch, and for stainless rivets up to 5/32 inch — a genuine plus, since stainless mandrels resist noticeably more than aluminum ones.
The HP-2 suits the home mechanic or fabricator who sets rivets now and then and wants one durable tool covering the common size range. It does not suit anyone facing a full day of riveting, because every fastener costs several squeezes and fatigue builds quickly. Note that no rivets are included, so a starter assortment in your planned sizes is a separate purchase.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Type | Manual two-handle hand riveter |
| Model | 39000 HP-2 |
| Rivet sizes | 3/32 to 3/16 in (steel and aluminum) |
| Stainless capacity | Up to 5/32 in |
| Included | Tool only; no rivets included |
Astro Pneumatic Tool 1423 Heavy Duty Hand Riveter
The Astro 1423 is the heavy-duty end of the manual side: a 13-inch two-hand lever riveter built for leverage on bigger fasteners. Its headline number is capacity. Where the other manual tools here stop at 3/16 inch, the 1423 reaches 1/4 inch rivets, and the listing includes five nosepieces covering 1/8, 5/32, 3/16, 1/5 and 1/4 inch. The long handles keep larger rivets manageable without a motor.
This is the manual pick for trailer, duct and light fabrication work where 1/4 inch rivets show up and a cordless platform purchase is hard to justify. It is not the pick for tight quarters or overhead work, since its size and two-hand operation need space and a stable stance. To be clear about the model: the 1423 is a blind rivet tool for standard pop rivets, nothing else.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Type | Manual two-hand lever riveter |
| Length | 13 in |
| Nosepieces | 5 included |
| Nosepiece sizes | 1/8, 5/32, 3/16, 1/5, 1/4 in |
| Max rivet size | 1/4 in |
Arrow RT188M One-Handed Pop Rivet Gun
The Arrow RT188M takes the opposite approach to the Astro: instead of two long handles, it is a compact one-handed manual riveter with a steel body. One hand works the tool while the other holds the workpiece, exactly what small repair jobs often need. It uses blind rivets in 3/32, 1/8, 5/32 and 3/16 inch, and Arrow positions it for metal, fabric, leather and auto repair work.
The RT188M suits the occasional user whose riveting is a handful of fasteners at a time: a loose bracket, a trim panel, a gutter section. It does not suit stainless rivets at the top of its size range or any volume work, because a one-handed squeeze delivers less force than the two-handle tools and tires the hand sooner. Within its limits, it is the simplest, most maneuverable manual option here.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Type | One-handed manual riveter |
| Body | Steel |
| Rivet sizes | 3/32, 1/8, 5/32, 3/16 in blind rivets |
Milwaukee 2550-20 M12 Rivet Tool
The Milwaukee 2550-20 opens the cordless side. It pulls 3/32, 1/8, 5/32 and 3/16 inch rivets in aluminum, steel and stainless steel, setting each one with a single trigger pull instead of repeated squeezing. Milwaukee’s maker figure is 450 1/8-inch steel rivets per charge on a 1.5Ah M12 pack — runtime that turns riveting from a chore into a routine step. The compact M12 format also keeps the tool easy to position in awkward spots.
The catch is platform economics. The 2550-20 is a bare tool, so the M12 battery and charger are separate purchases, and the kit version sold under a different model number is a different listing, not this one. If you already run M12 tools, this is an easy add. If you own no Milwaukee batteries, the true starting cost includes at least one pack and a charger, and the manual tools above look very sensible for light use.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Type | Cordless rivet tool, bare tool |
| Platform | Milwaukee M12 |
| Rivet sizes | 3/32, 1/8, 5/32, 3/16 in |
| Materials | Aluminum, steel, stainless steel |
| Rivets per charge | 450 (1/8 in steel, 1.5Ah M12 pack, maker figure) |
| Battery and charger | Not included |
DEWALT DCF403B 20V MAX XR Cordless Rivet Tool
The DEWALT DCF403B is the heavy hitter of this group. Its brushless motor delivers 2,100 lbf of pulling force, and it sets rivets from 3/32 to 3/16 inch in aluminum, steel and stainless steel. DEWALT rates it at up to 800 rivets per charge with the DCB203 2Ah battery, per the maker’s own footnote. That force and runtime suit users who rivet as a regular part of fabrication, duct installation or equipment assembly rather than as an occasional repair.
Like the Milwaukee, the DCF403B is a bare tool only, so it makes the most sense inside an existing DEWALT 20V MAX battery collection. Buyers starting from zero should weigh the battery and charger purchase alongside the tool. For a workshop already on the platform, this is the cordless pick with the most headroom: strongest pull, longest stated runtime, consistent sets.
| Spec | Detail |
|---|---|
| Type | Cordless rivet tool, bare tool |
| Platform | DEWALT 20V MAX XR |
| Motor | Brushless |
| Pulling force | 2,100 lbf |
| Rivet sizes | 3/32 to 3/16 in |
| Materials | Aluminum, steel, stainless steel |
| Rivets per charge | Up to 800 (with DCB203 2Ah battery, maker figure) |
| Battery and charger | Not included |
How to choose
Start with volume. If riveting means a few fasteners on a weekend repair, a manual tool finishes the job before a battery would even matter, and it still works after years in a drawer. If a single project involves dozens or hundreds of rivets, the cordless tools repay their platform cost in saved effort and uniform results.
Next, check rivet size and material against the tool. Most work falls inside 3/32 to 3/16 inch, which all five tools cover in aluminum and steel. Stainless rivets narrow the field: the Marson HP-2 is rated for stainless only up to 5/32 inch, while both cordless tools cover stainless across their full size range. Jobs built around 1/4 inch rivets point to the Astro 1423, the only pick here that reaches that size.
Then think about how you work. Two-handle manual tools give the most hand-powered force but need both hands and some room. A one-handed tool like the Arrow leaves a hand free to steady the work. Finally, be honest about batteries: both cordless picks are bare tools tied to one platform each, and neither battery fits the other brand. Owning the platform already is the strongest argument for cordless; owning neither is the strongest argument for a manual tool.
Who should skip
Skip the manual tools if hand strength or fatigue is a concern, or if your projects routinely run to hundreds of rivets: the squeezing adds up fast, and inconsistent hand force can leave uneven sets late in a session. Skip the cordless tools if you set a handful of rivets a year, since a bare tool plus battery and charger is a lot of shelf space for rare use, and skip a cordless model entirely if its battery platform is not the one you already own.
Also skip all five picks if your fasteners are threaded rivet nuts rather than blind rivets. Setting threaded inserts is a different job done by a different category of tool, and none of these riveters is made for it.
FAQ
Can a manual rivet gun handle stainless steel rivets?
Yes, within limits. The Marson HP-2 is rated by its maker for stainless rivets up to 5/32 inch, while its steel and aluminum range runs to 3/16 inch. Stainless mandrels take more force to pull and snap, so a two-handle tool handles them better than a one-handed model.
Do the cordless rivet tools come with a battery?
No. Both the Milwaukee 2550-20 and the DEWALT DCF403B are bare tools, so a battery and charger are separate purchases. The Milwaukee uses M12 and the DEWALT uses 20V MAX batteries; the two platforms are not interchangeable.
How many rivets can a cordless tool set on one charge?
Milwaukee states 450 1/8-inch steel rivets per charge on a 1.5Ah M12 pack; DEWALT states up to 800 per charge with its DCB203 2Ah battery. These are maker figures: larger rivets and stainless material draw more power and reduce the count.
What rivet sizes do these five tools cover?
Four of the five cover 3/32 to 3/16 inch, spanning the sizes used in most home and light workshop work. The Astro 1423 is the exception that goes bigger, reaching 1/4 inch rivets with its included nosepieces, suiting heavier sheet and structural repairs.
Final verdict
There is no single winner here, only a right match for the work. For occasional repairs, the Marson HP-2 is the manual default: proven two-handle design, full common size range, and a stated stainless rating. The Arrow RT188M is the lighter one-handed alternative, and the Astro 1423 is the manual choice when 1/4 inch rivets are on the list. For volume work, the DEWALT DCF403B brings the most pulling force and longest stated runtime, while the Milwaukee 2550-20 is the compact cordless option for shops already invested in M12. Count your rivets, check your battery shelf, and the decision makes itself.
Related articles



